Understanding cryptocurrency regulation in the U.S.

As the cryptoverse expands, governments worldwide are stepping in to regulate, addressing concerns like fraud, tax evasion, and security risks. Approaches vary widely – some countries foster innovation, while others impose stricter controls.

Among these global efforts, the United States has developed its own regulatory framework to encourage technological advancement while protecting consumers. 

In this guide, we’ll explore how cryptocurrency regulation has evolved domestically, examining the key players, policies, and challenges that have shaped the evolution of crypto in the U.S.

Who regulates cryptocurrency in the U.S.?

Cryptocurrency regulation in the U.S. involves multiple government bodies and federal agencies, each overseeing different aspects of digital assets: Congress, the Financial Crimes Enforcement Network (FinCEN), the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC), and the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC). Together, these institutions shape the legal framework surrounding cryptocurrency.

Congress

Congress plays a pivotal role in shaping the legal landscape for cryptocurrency in the U.S. through laws that establish clear standards for the industry. Congress is responsible for passing the bills that become law that dictate how crypto can be regulated in the U.S. One key example is the Financial Innovation and Technology for the 21st Century Act (FIT21), which aims to create a well-defined regulatory framework, addressing areas like taxation, consumer protection, and market manipulation. This legislation helps ensure that as the crypto space evolves, it does so within a structure that balances innovation with security. Legislation can ultimately help crypto grow or provide restrictions. The crypto industry is working hard on influencing positive legislation that helps grow the adoption of crypto by balancing the risks. 

Financial Crimes Enforcement Network (FinCEN)

FinCEN primarily focuses on preventing illicit activities such as money laundering and terrorism financing within the financial sector, including cryptocurrency. By enforcing the Bank Secrecy Act (BSA) and requiring compliance from financial institutions, FinCEN helps ensure that digital asset businesses implement safeguards to protect the integrity of the financial system.

Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC)

The SEC is responsible for regulating digital assets classified as securities. Its stated mission is to protect investors, ensure transparent markets, and prevent fraud. The SEC has been actively issuing guidelines and taking legal action against projects that fail to comply with securities laws. Over recent history, the SEC has taken a controversial approach to regulating crypto companies, using tactics such as issuing Wells Notices to brokers. The outcome of this strategy is yet to be seen.  

Commodities Futures Trading Commission (CFTC)

The CFTC oversees digital assets classified as commodities, such as Bitcoin (BTC), and regulates some derivatives trading platforms that offer crypto futures. Its primary goal is to ensure fair trading practices, and it has taken action against fraud or manipulation in both traditional and digital markets. However, the CFTC’s approach to crypto regulation is still developing, leading to some uncertainty about its jurisdiction, particularly in relation to the SEC’s role in overseeing securities-related cryptocurrencies.

What’s the goal of crypto regulation in the U.S.?

In its ideal state, cryptocurrency regulation should establish security and transparency, address investor protection, and create an environment where blockchain technology can thrive in the United States. 

Here’s a quick run-down:

Protect investors from market manipulation and crypto scams

Crypto regulation could prevent fraudulent schemes, pump-and-dump scams, and other malicious activities that distort market prices or exploit inexperienced investors. For example, in cases like the BitConnect Ponzi scheme, lack of regulatory oversight allowed the scam to run for years, costing investors billions. The SEC and CFTC work to enforce guidelines that protect against these types of manipulation.

Ensure investors receive accurate and helpful information

Accurate, timely information is critical for investors to make well-informed decisions. Regulations require cryptocurrency issuers and exchanges to disclose essential information about their assets and operations, similar to how publicly traded companies must provide financial disclosures. This helps reduce the risk of misinformation and allows investors to assess risks more effectively.

Prevent illicit activities

The anonymity of cryptocurrencies has made them attractive for illegal activities like money laundering and terrorist financing. Regulations like the BSA and anti-money laundering (AML) laws, enforced by FinCEN, require exchanges and financial institutions to verify the identity of their users and report suspicious transactions. These efforts aim to combat criminal activity while preserving the integrity of the financial system.

Clarify cryptocurrency tax regulations

Taxation of digital assets can be confusing, especially with the rapid growth of decentralized finance (DeFi) and non-fungible tokens (NFTs). Regulatory guidance from authorities like the Internal Revenue Service helps ensure that traders and businesses understand their tax obligations, reducing the risk of underreporting income or incorrectly calculating capital gains. This protects taxpayers and helps governments collect revenue fairly.

Boost investor confidence and market participation

Regulated markets give traders a sense of security that their investments are protected from fraud and misuse. A well-regulated crypto market attracts more participants, promoting growth and liquidity. For example, clear regulatory frameworks in countries like Switzerland have made it a hub for crypto startups, drawing institutional investors into the space.

Encourage novel developments with blockchain technology

When governments clarify the legal standing of digital assets, they encourage companies to embrace crypto without fear of sudden regulatory crackdowns. Clear rules around initial coin offerings (ICOs), security tokens, and stablecoins can promote the development of new applications in areas like DeFi, supply chain management, and cross-border payments. This support accelerates the growth of blockchain technology and its adoption across industries.

Promote interoperability among different blockchains

As the blockchain ecosystem grows, so does the need for seamless interoperability between different networks. Regulations that promote standardized protocols enhance the functionality of decentralized applications (dApps), improve cross-platform transaction efficiency, and lower costs, ultimately enriching the user experience.

Regulatory challenges in cryptocurrency

Regulating cryptocurrency has had its ups and downs, and finding the right balance between innovation and security remains a challenge. If regulations are too strict, they could stifle the growth of emerging technologies; if they’re too lenient, they could invite illegal activities like fraud or money laundering. This balancing act is made even more difficult by the fast-changing nature of the crypto market, which demands regulators constantly update their frameworks to stay relevant. Additionally, since digital assets operate on a global scale, international cooperation is crucial to maintain market integrity and prevent cross-border fraud.

Key challenges of crypto regulation include:

Classification issues

Cryptocurrencies like Bitcoin, Ethereum (ETH), and others serve multiple roles, such as commodities, securities, or currencies. This multifaceted nature makes it difficult for regulatory bodies to categorize these assets consistently. For example, Bitcoin is often seen as a store of value like gold, while Ethereum’s platform supports dApps and smart contracts, blurring the line between utility and currency. Without a clear framework for these varying use cases, misclassification and regulatory confusion are common.

Overregulation

Some argue that too many regulatory hurdles could harm the crypto industry, especially smaller companies or startups. Excessive rules may discourage innovation and restrict the development of new blockchain-based technologies, making it harder for crypto companies to thrive. Policymakers face the difficult task of creating rules that protect investors and prevent illegal activity while allowing room for innovation and growth.

Global coordination

Cryptocurrency is borderless, and different countries have taken vastly different approaches to regulation. For example, El Salvador has embraced Bitcoin as a legal tender, while China has outright banned cryptocurrency transactions. This discrepancy complicates enforcement and creates opportunities for regulatory arbitrage, where companies move operations to less regulated jurisdictions. International cooperation is necessary to ensure cohesive, global standards for managing digital assets, especially when dealing with issues like tax evasion or money laundering.

New blockchain paradigm

Blockchain’s decentralized structure poses significant challenges to traditional regulatory frameworks. Unlike centralized institutions, DeFi platforms and decentralized autonomous organizations (DAOs) operate without a central authority, making it difficult for regulators to enforce laws. Advancements like stablecoins and central bank digital currencies (CBDCs) are also forcing regulators to rethink how they apply existing financial rules to the digital space. As blockchain technology evolves, regulators must adapt quickly to ensure that new innovations don’t fall outside the scope of legal oversight.

Stay aligned with cryptocurrency regulation in the U.S.

As a user, with fluctuating markets, evolving tax laws, and constant regulatory changes, managing your crypto portfolio can feel overwhelming. CoinTracker gives you the freedom to sync your wallets, track your investments in real time, and generate accurate tax forms – all while helping you stay compliant with the latest crypto laws.

Plus, with CoinTracker's robust security, you can manage your assets with confidence. Join the more than 2 million users who trust CoinTracker to maximize their crypto gains and simplify tax reporting. Start for free today.

Disclaimer: This post is informational only and is not intended as tax advice. For tax advice, please consult a tax professional.